Thursday, February 21, 2013

TRAVELING SOLO: WHIRLING DERVISHES





THE VICISSITUDES OF TRAVELING SOLO Part II: WHIRLING DERVISHES

2000 KONYA, TURKEY

In “Traveling Solo: Part One” I described my good luck in connecting with Ahmed who helped me use the phone, find a hotel, and then led me to the soccer stadium where I secured the last ticket to the Whirling Dervish performance. Had I been traveling with a friend, I would have been reluctant to give up the seat to her, but also unwilling to take it for myself. So, in this instance, traveling alone saved me from having to deal with that dilemma.

A couple of hours after Ahmed left me at the hotel I retraced my steps to the stadium where the performance would take place. I scarcely recognized the bright new look flooding the streets. Gone were the frumpy, gray cloaks that dominated the scene earlier that afternoon. Hundreds of splendidly dressed men and women poured out of tour buses. Men wore western suits. Women were draped in fashionable, flowing silk scarves. The stadium, a cavernous cold, gray place, was made lively by men and women selling beads, sweets, images of saints and other religious trinkets. The marriage of commerce and holiness -common as it is - always surprised me. I wondered what Mevlana would have made of it all. 

Mevlana, born Celaleddin Rumi in 1207, escaped massacre by Mongols in central Asia, settled in Konya, and became a much beloved Sufi mystic and poet. He instructed his followers to “pursue all manifestations of truth and beauty, whilst avoiding ostentation,” and to “practice infinite tolerance, love and charity.” Mevlana revered music and dance, and founded the Whirling Dervishes, or sema, which is believed to create union with God.  

My assigned seat was high up in the stadium, and it was hot. I hadn’t slept enough the night before, and I soon felt overwhelmed by drowsiness, unable to stay fully awake, yet too uncomfortable to fall asleep. I was relieved when a couple of dozen musicians finally entered the far end of a stage, so small and distant it was dwarfed by the rest of the huge stadium. The musicians set up long metallic looking tubes and string instruments in shapes I had never seen. From my seat half way to Heaven, I couldn’t see them clearly. 

The sounds began. Low dirge-like emanations alternated with higher, almost screeching, notes. If there was a rhythm or melody, it escaped me. A man stepped to a microphone and spoke in a low sonorous drone, perhaps explaining what had been played or what we were about to hear. I wished I could understand. Where was Ahmed when I needed him? I might even have welcomed a guide. But if I were a mystic, maybe I wouldn’t need to understand the literal words. I might simply intuit the message. A mystic probably wouldn’t be distracted by the hard bench with no back.

Other speakers, including two women, alternated with the music. Mevlana, according to my guidebook, had advocated a higher status for women in religious and public life. Perhaps he would have been pleased to hear the women speaking. At times I thought the performers were praying, at others they sounded like poets. Perhaps for Mevlana, a religious poet, it was all the same. The recitations soothed me, nudging me even closer to a desperate need to sleep. As my head drooped, I silently complained that they hadn’t started their ecstatic dancing to wake me up.

After half an hour we were given a break, and I didn’t know whether to be sorrowful or glad. The glad part was the opportunity to take a little walk, a moment’s respite from my sleepy doldrums. The negative side was that I would have to endure still another wait. On the stairs and in the hallways women and men I thought of as "trinketeers" peddled holy medals and images, and crowds gathered around them, eager to buy. 

The intermission had energized me, and I returned to my seat fully alert. Soon, men dressed in ankle length black cloaks entered the court in a two-by-two procession. The pace was funereal. Slowly, each man discarded his cloak.  I had read that the tall camel’s hair hats they wore represented a tombstone. The cloak stood for the tomb itself, and the white gowns for the shroud. Shedding the cloaks symbolized leaving the tomb, and casting off all earthly ties. Entering into this ethereal world would be a challenge for me, but its very strangeness intrigued me. This was what foreign travel was about, wasn’t it?

Taking small, graceful, stylized steps, each pair of men, about twenty paces apart from each other, inched around the arena. There were perhaps a dozen duos, in all. The stadium floor seemed as large as a football field, and it took slightly less than forever to traverse just one side of it. At the far end of the arena the seyh, or current head man, awaited each pair, who turned toward him briefly, then bowed to each other. The seyh leaned forward and appeared to kiss each of them on the tops of their heads. The pair straightened, making room for the next pair to approach, bend, bow and, receive the kiss. They then proceeded to twirl around the other side of the arena. Was this the twirling? The performers were turning around and around, but not at the fast pace I had expected. Slowly, they advanced around the periphery of the arena several times. I had arrived at 8:30. It was now 10:10. 

At last. What seems to be more serious whirling begins. Cloaks gone, each man’s white gown, with its full A-line cut, creates a swirl of soft white. Expectantly, I wait for the dancers to spin faster, and faster and faster, toward a state of ecstasy. That is my fantasy about ecstasy. As a child I had delighted in holding my arms straight out from my sides, while I spun around and around as fast as possible, thoroughly dizzy, until I collapsed onto the ground in a paroxysm of joy and confusion. Ecstasy. But in watching the performers, that childhood association turns out to be way off the mark. 

The dancers continue at the same pace, still in pairs, and gradually circle the court, as they whirl opposite each other. Twirling, whirling, still slowly, their delicate steps resemble no dance I have seen. Skirts flow gracefully around them. With each twirl they advance a few steps until every pair has made the revolution of the arena, and then they float around again. There is something almost girlish, something very sweet, about the sameness of the pace, the steps, the billowing skirts. The dancers, my guide book says, represent the heavenly bodies, revolving in their own space, at the same time as they revolve around the court. There are three stages of the dance: knowledge of God, awareness of God’s presence, and union with God. But I am unable to distinguish one from the other. Each performer points his right hand upward, and his left to the floor. This gesture signifies that grace emanates from the heavens and is distributed to the people. The Dervishes represent the symbolic conduit. 

I am mesmerized. As if mimicking the dancers, I float in an ephemeral universe, coasting along, somewhere between sleep and wakefulness. But now I’m content to bask forever in that altered state. I would not call it ecstasy. I am not in a condition that’s frenetic, excited, or high. It feels closer to zoned out. Dreamy. Or meditative. Whatever it is, I’m content with it.

But, ever so slowly, deliberately, as if in a trance, the dancers once more pull their black cloaks around their shoulders. It is as if a reel is running backwards, at the same languorous pace as the whirling began. I postpone facing the reality that the performance - and my wondrous, mental free-fall - will soon disappear. I am not yet ready to re-enter the frenetic, jangling world. The dancers make their round of the court one more time and then they are gone, wafting off the stage, like ether. They have spirited themselves away, but left me in a state of serenity. I am aware of a faint smile on my face, and hazily remember that once I might have called such an expression sappy. Now I am pleased to be in the lap of a tradition where all is foreign to me.

I muse about the meaning of the dancers’ religious ecstasy, and try to prepare for my transition into worldliness. Lazily, I let my gaze sweep over the vast stadium walls, which are covered with dark red drapes of rich velvet. In graceful folds, they fall from ceiling to floor. White loops of what is apparently Arabic script appear. Their graceful curves, mysterious to my Western sensibility, dance across the cloth, and I am enchanted. Do they spell out a prayer? A poem? With my eye, I trace them. But a moment later a slight shift in the drape makes the white lettering clearer. The “graceful curves” spell out a different message in very different, very large letters:

COCA COLA

Monday, February 4, 2013

MY FRIEND IS DEAD BUT HER VALUES LIVE ON


         My beloved friend Ruth Goodman died yesterday at the age of ninety-one. Over the last fifty-three years, Ruth and I grew even closer and more important to each other than we were in the early days of our protesting the Vietnam War. So my loss is great, but mitigated by remembering Ruth’s dedicated activism in several political campaigns, including the movement for Death with Dignity. She died as she lived, true to her principles.
            
           It is one thing to say you will take your own life when the time is right. It is quite another to follow through and do it. The right to die with dignity was as important to Ruth as the other civil and human rights she had championed, so I felt confident that she would put her beliefs into action. When, shortly before her death, I wrote her obituary, she made sure I included the (anticipated) fact that right to the end she was in control of her death. It was my privilege to spend the last five days of Ruth's life with her, and the day before she died she wrote this letter to be sent to newspaper editors after her death:

I am a ninety-one-year-old woman who has decided to end my life in the very near future. I do not have a terminal illness; I am simply old, tired and becoming dependent, after a wonderful life of independence. People are allowed to choose the right time to terminate their animals’ lives and to be with them and provide assistance and comfort, right to the end. Surely, the least we can do is allow people the same right to choose how and when to end their lives. By the time people read this, I will have died. I am writing this letter to advocate for a change in the law so that all will be able to make this choice.

As far as the eye could see we were they only white folks present among for the Black Mambhzaza concert. Thousands of dancing, drinking, joyously welcoming black folks graciously welcomed us.
Ruth is dead, but her courageous work for Death with Dignity lives on.
We had heard numerous sad, infuriating stories about the way blacks were treated by the South African apartheid government, but there were many moments of joy as well, and Ruth had a smile on her face every day. She said this adventure in South African was the best of all her trips, and being part of the huge crowd that filled a soccer field to hear Black Mambhzaza's music was a welcome relief from the horrifying stories we had heard.



Ruth always said she wanted to "go out dancing" and she came might close to doing that.
People danced on rooftops and the hills around the field, and if you look closely you can see Ruth having the time of her life in the crowd. When she tired of dancing she wound up resting with someone's little boy by her side. I feel confident that she would like seeing this part of her wonderful life remembered here.


Obituary for Ruth Goodman

            Ruth Goodman has led a life of resistance to war, a commitment to the environment and social justice. Her family fled Eastern Europe at the turn of the last century to escape war and anti-Semitism. Ruth grew up in a union household, and in 1940 she married Henry Goodman. She found a job in the shipyards where, as a clerical worker, she was paid $20 a week. When she discovered that welders made $1.25 an hour she joined the wave of women’s participation in wartime industrial production.
            After the war, Ruth and Henry moved to Washington State, where Ruth gave birth to two sons, Michael and Dean. Soon she joined the American Friends Service Committee, organizing annual peace marches, and picketing the Boeing Company in protest of their manufacturing aircraft used in the Vietnam War.
            In 1966, worried about their sons becoming eligible for the draft in a few years, Ruth and Henry left the United States to settle in Vancouver, Canada. But their anti-war activism didn’t stop there. They offered U.S. draft resisters a safe haven in their home, and Ruth volunteered at the War Resisters’ support office. But her participation in political campaigns was not confined to international issues.
Through her personal experience of two illegal abortions in the late 1940s and early 1950s, Ruth developed a heightened awareness of the importance of a woman’s right to reproductive choice, including abortion. Her strong belief in the right to legal and safe access to abortion led her to be among the first volunteers for the Everywoman’s Health Centre, an abortion clinic.
Ruth’s life-long commitment to justice has made her a staunch advocate of the right to Death with Dignity, and she died true to her principles. With the support of her children and a host of devoted friends, at the age of ninety-one on February 2nd, 2013, Ruth chose to end her life. She is survived by Michel Goodman and his partner Sharon Sjerven, Dean Goodman and his wife, Janna Levitt, as well as grandsons, Henry, Eric and Gabriel Goodman.
            To carry on his parents’ commitments to justice, Michael Goodman has established the Ruth and Henry Goodman Fund for Social and Economic Justice. Instead of flowers, donations may be made to that organization. http://ruthandhenrygoodmanfund.com/